Circle selloff may miss the mark as Clarity Act targets distributors, not issuers: Bernstein
A sharp selloff in Circle shares has run ahead of the underlying risk, according to Bernstein, which argues investors are misreading proposed U.S. stablecoin rules.
Circle's shares (CRCL) fell about 20% in the prior session and briefly slipped toward $100 before stabilizing near $104 in premarket trading, according to The Block's CRCL price page. The drop has been tied to draft provisions in the Clarity Act that would restrict yield on stablecoin balances.
Bernstein’s note cuts against that narrative, suggesting the market reaction has blurred key differences in how stablecoin economics actually work. Analysts from the research and brokerage firm asserted that the rules focus on distribution, not issuance.
"Don’t conflate stablecoin issuer with distributor," Bernstein analysts led by Gautam Chhugani wrote, noting that Circle earns income on reserves while platforms such as Coinbase pass yield through to users.
Under the proposal, platforms would be barred from offering yield on passive stablecoin balances in ways that resemble bank interest. Activity-based rewards tied to usage — such as trading or payments — would still be allowed, with regulators given time to define the boundary.
Circle’s model sits outside that restriction, analysts opined.
The company invests roughly $80 billion backing its USDC (USDC) stablecoin into short-term U.S. Treasurys and earns the spread, generating about $2.64 billion in reserve income in 2025. It does not, however, pay yield directly to token holders.
It’s Bernstein’s view that this distinction matters. The yield debate has often centered on whether stablecoins compete by passing returns to users. Bernstein argues that limiting those payouts could even strengthen Circle’s position by reducing incentives for competitors to attract liquidity through aggressive yield offers.
More impact on intermediaries
Analysts said the more immediate impact would fall on intermediaries. Coinbase, which offers around 3.5% yield on USDC balances and shares roughly half of USDC reserve income with Circle, may need to rework its rewards structure under the new rules.
Even there, Bernstein sees room to adapt. Platforms could shift toward engagement-based incentives while retaining users drawn to trading and onchain activity rather than passive yield alone.
Demand for USDC has continued to expand beyond yield considerations. Supply has grown from roughly $30 billion to $80 billion over the past two years, driven by trading collateral, cross-border payments, and corporate treasury use. Onchain transaction volume reached $11.9 trillion in the fourth quarter of 2025 as well.
The analysts maintained an outperform rating on both Circle and Coinbase, with price targets of $190 and $440, respectively, pointing to continued long-term upside tied to stablecoin adoption and payment use cases.
Indeed, Bernstein recently identified the company, alongside Coinbase, as one of the clearest public-market proxies for stablecoin growth as digital dollar usage expands into payments and financial infrastructure.
Gautam Chhugani maintains long positions in various cryptocurrencies. Certain affiliates of Bernstein act as market makers or liquidity providers in the equity securities of Circle and Coinbase.
Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.
You may also like
Here’s why BlackRock believes autonomous AI systems will drive next stablecoin boom
BlackRock expects exchange-traded compute futures as it pitches stablecoins for AI agents
Report: TSMC to Raise Wafer Foundry Prices by 3% to 6% Starting January Next Year, Order Visibility Extended to 2030
According to media reports, TSMC's advanced and high-priced processes such as 2nm and 3nm have seen the largest price increases; mature and specialty processes are subject to individual negotiation based on products, capacity utilization, and customer conditions. Currently, TSMC's 8-inch fabs have a capacity utilization rate exceeding 100%, and processes below 45nm are at full capacity. The construction of AI data centers is not only driving demand for GPU and HBM, but also boosting orders for mature processes such as PMIC, MCU, and analog ICs.
U.S. Treasury plans to repurchase up to $6 billion in long-term bonds, 30-year yield hits highest since 2007
This is the second round of enhanced long-term bond buybacks by the Treasury, this time focusing on 20- to 30-year government bonds. After the announcement of the planned upper limit, the yield on 30-year U.S. Treasury bonds continued to rise, at one point exceeding 5.4%. In the first round of enhanced buybacks two weeks ago, the upper buyback target was also $6 billion, which was lower than some market participants had expected, and the actual buyback amounted to only $5.2 billion due to insufficient competitive bidding, according to the Treasury.
